The Hobbit - An Unexpected Disappointment ??

It took awhile, but I was finally able to get my copy of the Hobbit Trilogy on DVD.  I decided against blue-ray because I wanted to be able to watch it in my craft room as well as on the big screen TV.

When I first heard The Hobbit was going to be filmed, I was pretty excited about it.  The Lord of the Rings was everything I expected it to be, so I figured this will be great too.  I went to see it by myself as my usual movie buddy doesn't like fantasy/sci-fi all that much.  It started off good, so nice to be back in Middle Earth, but then along came this weird wizard named Radagast who had a sleigh pulled by giant rabbits and I was like WTF?  I can honestly say I had a hard time watching the rest of the movie because of it.  Now I know it's not uncommon to make some changes when going from the page to the screen, but this was a bit much and at the end, I left the theater a little bewildered at what I just saw.  I had intentions of seeing the other two films, but never did go to the theater for them.  All because adding Radagast to the story didn't sit well with me (and I'm usually not that picky about book to movie changes) !  Silly girl. LOL

Fast forward to 2015 and the PBS presentation of Poldark starring you-know-who... Aidan Turner.  I'm smitten.  Oh, more than that. LOL    It wasn't until my obsession that I realized the one dwarf that I thought was kind of cute was played by Aidan.  Well that did it.  Since I made it my mission to see every film/show he ever did, I borrowed it from the library to re-watch it and lo and behold, I enjoyed it so much more and not just because of adorable Kili (Aidan).  Now I was over the changes, I appreciated the whole production so much more.

 

The casting, sets, and costuming were amazing, as I had expected, yet was too piqued to notice!  So, though feeling a little silly for my Sheldon-like feelings towards The Unexpected Journey, I borrowed The Desolation of Smaug, and after that, The Battle of Five Armies.

I got totally invested in the Tauriel/Kili romance (no surprise there).  I was horrified by the ending and even had to drag out the book to confirm the demise of Kili and Fili.  It had been awhile since I read the book, so as often is the case, I had forgotten all but the most major parts of the story.

Recently someone asked me which movie did I like best and I said I liked them all, but I think Desolation of Smaug has a slight edge because of that sweet scene where Tauriel heals Kili from the goblin poison.  I have watched it several times and I sill wonder why she didn't say anything when he asked her 'do you think she could have loved me'.  Would it have been better if she had answered?  I don't know for sure. What do you think?

I really applaud the casting people for finding the spot-on perfect actors for each role, especially Bilbo.  Martin Freeman was born to play young Bilbo, just as Ian Holm was born to play old Bilbo.  I'm always ecstatic over perfect casting as many of you know already.  I felt that way about Lord of the Rings and now this trilogy too.

If those of you reading this haven't taken the time to watch the appendices with the magic behind the making of the movie, I urge you to do so, and then re-watch all three movies again.  It will be all that more impressive if you do!

All-in-all, The Hobbit Trilogy was a lovely venture back to Middle Earth, in spite of the changes.  If you felt a bit lukewarm about it when it was first released, as I did, give it another try and see if you find it was better than you first thought it was.

Click on link below to see my favorite scene

 Do you think she could have loved me?